Loyal Oaks Golf Course (Norton, OH)

Loyal Oaks has the coolest backstory you’ll ever hear. It was owned by 1946 Masters’ winner Herman Keiser. His green jacket is on full display safely tucked in a wooden frame glass case. Thought the winner had to give it back? Me too but apparently Herman decided otherwise! 

The 1946 Masters was the first one after  WWII. There was no tournament from ‘43-‘45. Ben Hogan was the presumptive favorite but Herman Keiser entered already having a pretty solid year. He was runner up in Phoenix to Hogan just a few months earlier. Herman began the week 69-68 which was good for a five shot lead. A 71 on Saturday maintained that lead, however, Ben Hogan shot 69 to jump into second place. The leader is supposed to go off in the last group, but they decided to have Keiser go off in the third to last group, completely disrespecting his position. It was one of several incidents that upset Keiser. They gave him a 13 year old caddy that he had to swap out later in his round. On the eighteenth, Keiser’s approach shot hit the flag, finishing twenty feet away. Alas he would three putt, paving the way for Hogan to secure a playoff with a par, however, Hogan would three putt himself from fifteen feet, cruelly missing a two footer. 

Loyal Oaks is a 27 hole golf facility. The original eighteen was designed in 1928 and the third nine was added in 1945. I was able to walk the course one night after work, and I was duly impressed by the topography of the land, the look of the pushed up greens, and the overall beauty of this serene, unadulterated natural setting. The course has a beautiful roll to it with the fairways having interesting tilt to them. Loyal Oaks tops out just over 6,200 from the tips, but it’s par of 70 includes several strong holes that keep scoring to a minimum. Both one and ten are long par fours that go downhill. While they play shorter, six and eighteen climb the opposite direction and play longer. Eight and sixteen are both long par threes with the later a stout 238 yards. Seventeen caught my attention with an almost punchbowl green sitting in a slight dell. If I ever have an afternoon to kill, I might sit at the library and try to find the architect of record. Everything about the place hints at it being noteworthy. 

This is the ninth green, a 357 yard par four. Look how it takes advantage of a slight crease in the land. The grass bunkers are beautifully cut into the green with a small ribbon of fairway providing a minuscule entrance. Such features are noteworthy architecture. 

The conditioning of the course reminds me of the places I grew up on. The fairway cut and rough look different, but not by much. There’s weeds and crab grass in spots. The greens looked beautiful but they’re carpet like and don’t have the speed one would fear. It simply categorizes itself as user friendly and playable. If this place was anywhere near the conditions of Chippewa (several miles down the road) then I would bet it would be as popular as Akron’s muni Goodpark. As is, the place is totally empty on a gorgeous weekday evening when most are filled with golfers on nine hole leagues. Note the picture above with a hose connected to a sprinkler head like they did it back when I first took up the game. I got the feeling Loyal Oaks is more than happy growing the game. The rate is very modest and their website repeatedly talks about junior golfers. I give it two thumbs up although it has bones to be a solid 5. 

Sports Illustrated Herman Keiser interview 

https://vault.si.com/vault/1997/04/21/going-back-for-50-years-herman-keiser-has-made-a-journey-to-augusta-thats-partly-a-pilgrimage-partly-a-trip-down-memory-lane

Charleston Municipal Golf Course (Charleston, SC)

The past twenty years golf architecture has really branched out and taken some chances. All on the public side too. Tom Doak did a reversible course at The Loop; Arcadia South employed geometric design like the ultra exclusive Chicago Golf Club; The Muni brought template greens to a John Q public facility owned by the city of Charleston.

(The 515 yard par five seventh hole plays to this monstrous elevated green. It’s at least 10’ high! Reaching this in two and holding the putting surface will require maximum skill. Beware the fool who gets too cute and leaves his shot short. Those bunkers are XX deep! Great golf hole!) 

If you’re not familiar with template greens, then you might think they’re over the top. The premise is simply accessing particular slopes to funnel the ball to precise locations. It’s more of a ground game attack then it is an aerial one. Charleston Municipal is on a flat piece of land with all the greens built up. Many of the putting surfaces are not visible so course knowledge goes a long way. “Don’t shoot at the flag” is a common piece of advice for visitors. Doing so usually results in a ball off the green and down the slope into the rough or fairway. It’s a style not seen that often in America. For locals and astute golfers, seeing the path to the pin via a spot thirty feet away is a real pleasure, especially when it reacts the exact way you envisioned it. 

(The “Double Plateau” opening hole has two raised levels bisected by a deep swale.) 
 

The 11th-14th is the stretch many consider to be the best at The Muni and all four are concepts most have heard before. Eleven is Redan. The green has a massive slope on the front right that will funnel balls that hit it back to the left and closer to the hole. It literally sits next to Maybank Highway, the two lane road that leads to Kiawah, and stuns golfers who stare at it with its massive contours. Twelve is Cape where you decide how much of the water you want to bite off. Thirteen is Road. A Principal Nose bunker forces a decision between left or right side of the fairway. The greenside bunker is bulky and protrudes into the green. The concept is avoiding these two traps as you find an angle to the pin. The fourteenth is Short. The par three has a long narrow thumbprint in the middle of the green that challenges the putter when you have to roll the ball from one side to the other. Being on the proper side makes this a birdie hole. 

(The 175 yard par three eleventh is called Redan. Look at the high slope in the right corner that pushes balls back to the left. Most of the green slopes away, making the putting surface over the bunker out of sight to the golfer.) 

The Muni is rough around the edges. It doesn’t pretend to be something more than it is. There’s a lot of imperfection. Maybe that’s why I’m drawn to it. The live oaks and Spanish moss give it that low country feeling and the burgers at the clubhouse grille are downright fantastic. Unlike The Park, West Palm Beach’s super muni and it’s $250 price tag, The Muni is intimate and welcoming. It’s $60 to walk and you’re just as likely to be paired with a blue jeans/tee shirt regular Joe as you are an Ashworth shirted country clubber. I’m sure the template greens won’t be everybody’s cup of tea. They’re whimsical and don’t always reward good shots. But if you’re looking for something exciting, and want to explore turn of century golf architecture, then check The Muni out. I give it a 6 (very good)(worth driving two hours to play). 

(The 405 yard par four sixth is called Punchbowl. This is the first I’ve seen where a high shot must carry over a gaping bunker. Don’t even look at the pin. The ball will gather most times in the center if you hit a quality shot.) 

(The 365 yard par four third has this unique hazard crossing the fairway. I love the randomness and uncertainty that arises if you hit it in there.) 

(This is the side view of the road bunker and green on the 370 yard par four thirteenth. Look how deep the shoulder influences approach shots. A beautiful view in the background.) 

Wild Dunes - Links Course (Isle of Palm, SC)

Wild Dunes is the real deal! After playing the Ocean Course, I was expecting a complete letdown. The first four holes were not changing my mind, but then the fifth caught my attention, a cool par five with a punchbowl green atop a slight rise. The sixth and seventh followed with a couple strong par fours. At the turn, the short par four tenth climbed a massive sand dune with heaving rolls reminiscent of the pounding surf. It was a genuine “cool” moment, and began a four hole stretch that showcased the talent of Tom Fazio. The final three holes arrive at the ocean and are fantastic. Kiawah would kill to have this sequence at Turtle Point. 

#73 World Top 100 (Golf Magazine)

#91 Top 100 USA Public (Golf Digest)

#93 Top 100 USA Public (Golf Magazine) 

The Links was designed in 1980 and was Tom Fazio’s first solo effort. (Just this fact makes Wild Dunes architecturally significant) It was a very innovative design at the time, and brought people back to the fundamentals of designing in the sand and by the beach. It’s not a surprise that the original 18th hole graces Ron Whiten’s book The Golf Course. Unfortunately, everything changed when Hurricane Hugo wiped out the 17th and 18th holes, and striped all the property of the old oak trees that gave it its cool character. The Links is no longer the course that received all those accolades, the seventeenth was rebuilt, and par five eighteenth had to be abandoned and made into a par three. (Mike Strantz is the one responsible for these new versions. Not that I’m an expert, but the eighteenth does remind me of his work at Monterey). 

(The 508 yard par five fifth ends at a saddled hill with two bunkers carved into each mound. Proper positioning off the tee is the only way to reach the green in two. Cool third shot since only the top of the flagstick is visible.) 

The Isle of Palm is nothing like Kiawah. It’s a crush of people and condominiums. I noticed a lot of younger golfers in their 20s and 30s. The course has a cool vibe because of it. It’s neat to think that Wild Dunes started as one of the best in the country, lost its shine due to forces beyond its control, and has found its place among a group of people that isn’t just a bunch of old dudes. 

(The 192 yard par three twelfth is an optical illusion. All the sea grass and mounding makes it look tight but there’s plenty of room to hit your shot.) 

(The 427 yard par four thirteenth is a slight dogleg left that plays to a high back left to low front right green.) 

Wild Dunes makes me want to go back and look at the old Top 100 lists just to see what’s fallen off. It’s still a really good golf course. For golfers going to Charleston and Kiawah, this is a fine addition. It’s comparable in price to Osprey and Turtle ($205). The setting on the last two holes is second only to the Ocean Course. I give it a 6 (very good)(worth driving two hours to play). 

(The 185 yard par three eighteenth plays into the wind with the white sand dunes and ocean in the background. I love how the fairway comes in at a slight angle. A low shot on that line will be scuttled away to a difficult up n down. The optimal shot is over the sand with a slight left to right bias. This is the best par three finishing hole I’ve seen since Pasatiempo.) 

[We played the 6002 yard white tees. Check out the course and slope rating from both the black and white tees. The course is only a par 70. It was a great way to end our Charleston/Kiawah golf trip!) 

Ocean Course - Kiawah Island Club (Kiawah Island, SC)

#62 World Top 100 (Golf Magazine)

#43 World Top 100 (Golf Digest)

#33 World Top 100 (Architects)

#52 World Top 100 (Golf World)

#24 Top 100 USA (Golf Digest)

#32 Top 100 USA (Golf Magazine)

#9   Top 100 World Resort (Golf World)

#14 Top 100 USA Modern (Golfweek)

#3   Top 100 USA Public (Golf Digest)

#6   Top 100 USA Public (Golf Magazine)

#9   Top 100 USA Public (Golfweek)

..It took thirty years to get back to the Ocean Course…

There’s certain places that every golfer should make an effort to see. No matter what the cost. For the public golfer, with no access to private venues, the Ocean Course is the crème de la crème. Set between the Atlantic Ocean and the saltwater marshes of the Intercoastal, it’s an experience you won’t find anywhere else in the United States. 

(The 495 yard (blue tee) par five second hole is reachable in two shots by the long hitter, but with so much trouble close by, leaving it in the fairway left gives the best chance for birdie. The majority of players will layup to the creek and hit short or mid iron approach. It’s a very difficult green to hold, so beware going long and right. Par is a great score!) 

The drive out to the course maybe one of the most anticipated moments I’ve ever had. With every turn, the landscape entices you with gorgeous views before ending at the beautiful white antebellum looking clubhouse. The scene from the rear veranda is breathtaking! The long view across the dunes and beach to the rolling surf heightens the senses. In my travels, only a few places have captured my spirit in such a way. 

(In the 2021 PGA Championship, Rory McIroy’s drive hung up in this tree short of three green. It’s a 310 yards (blue tee) par four that possesses the smallest green on the course. The plateau putting surface requires a crisp iron shot to hold it. Anything long will go into the marsh.) 

In his book Bury Me in a Pot Bunker, Pete Dye commented after Hurricane Hugo, the central dune that ran through the property was reduced to a series of smaller ones. His wife Alice suggested raising the fairways so the ocean was in view from every hole. Pete took this advice and the experience is tenfold better for it. Unfortunately, this makes the wind more of a factor. During our round, it was blowing a mild 10-15 mph. I didn’t have to make any adjustments for it. The Ocean Course is walking only and requires a caddy, so I let him give me the playing yardage, and hit the club that went that distance. On several occasions I doubt I would’ve figured it out. 

(The 398 yard (blue tee) par four twelfth plays downhill the last 150 yards and offers a stunning view of the saltwater marsh eating into the hole.) 

(Wow!! The 333 yard (blue tee) par four thirteenth asks so many questions. The optimal line is right of the fairway bunker but it looks so narrow. The water is right in your face. It takes complete confidence to strike it pure. The championship tee is unbelievable!) 

My favorite holes were 2,3,12,13. All play along the marsh. I felt the contrast between all the colors and various textures was gorgeous. Pete Dye’s fascination with the plateau green is seen several times including 2,3,8,11,14. Interestingly, there’s no bunkers short of the putting surface on these holes, however, the slopes are so abrupt that bouncing it in is nonexistent. The seashore paspalum prevents much roll anyway. Only a well struck shot will hit and hold these. Going long is the big no-no. The worst spots are back there. On the par three eighth, my ball didn't bite quick enough and went in the back bunker. I spun the bunker shot ten feet from the hole which my caddy said was the best bunker shot he’s seen in two weeks. Usually golfers play ping pong going back and forth from one waste area to another. 

(The 161 yard (blue tee) par three fourteenth is a devil to hit in regulation. The green slopes from front to back. Note how the left bunker is grassed down almost to the base. During the Senior PGA Championship, the leader plugged his ball into the face and took two to get out, losing the tournament in the process. I found that bunker, a good ten feet below the green. I hit it to fifteen feet.) 

The Ocean Course is unquestionably one of the finest in the world. Pete Dye jokingly said he would’ve traded his wife in for a chance to design on piece of property like it. It’s a setting we haven’t seen in this country since the turn of the century. The PGA of America has made it one of their stalwarts and it has hosted the 1991 Ryder Cup, 1997 & 2003 World Cup, 2005 PGA Club Professional, 2007 Senior PGA Championship, and the 2012 & 2021 PGA Championship. I don’t really need to add much more than that. It’s my third perfect score. I give it a 10 (perfect)(must play once in your life). In 2031, it will host its third PGA Championship. 

(The par three seventeenth is a 161 yards (blue tee) that plays into a hurting cross wind. It doesn’t necessarily fit in with rest of the course, but the donor die high drama has been the site of many infamous moments.) 

[we played the blue tees at 6,202 yards. The yardage was perfect and gave us some opportunities to make a few birdies. Check out Tim, a 22 handicap. He parred the toughest hole and made a 65 footer for birdie on eleven! A couple nice 4 for 2 moments!] 

[The cost of the round was $480 dollars, plus a caddy is mandatory which adds another $125. The total is a whopping $605! (Don’t choke reading that number again) We all knew the deal before stepping on the plane. YOLO]

The other two 10s:

Whistling Straits

http://golfingwithshawn.blogspot.com/2018/06/whistling-straits-kohler-wi.html?m=1

Pacific Dunes

http://golfingwithshawn.blogspot.com/2017/09/pacific-dunes-bandon-dunes-resort.html?m=1

Turtle Point - Kiawah Island Club (Kiawah Island, SC)

Turtle Point’s entire reputation hinges around three holes 14-15-16 that play alongside the Atlantic Ocean. Two par threes bookend a short par four. As much fun as it is to reach the shore, the holes, in my opinion, are disappointing. They’re wedged between the villas and the dune, and are really tight. There’s little room for error. The green on fourteen, the best looking hole of the three, is a two level affair with the rear significantly higher than the front. It’s the only green at Turtle Point that does this! It’s so out of place that it’s shocking when you first see it! And the biggest kicker?! You never see the ocean during this stretch because the dune is too high. 

(The fourteenth green occupies a beautiful location in the dunes. Even though pictures tend to flatten out slope, you can still make out the height difference between the back tier, where the pin is located, and the front where the pin shot marker is. The dip between them is even evident.) 

Jack Nicklaus designed Turtle Point in 1981. Most of the holes play in the lush environs of Kiawah Island. (We saw more gators here than anywhere else.) The interior holes are solid, if not exciting. Water guards eight greens, and surprisingly, five times it’s on the left. This should bail out many of the resort golfers who are hitting a left to right shot. 

(Jack does a good job giving golfers plenty of room to bail out. The sixth is a fine par four with plenty of short grass right and long of the green. While par is a good score, weaker players who hit smart shots can secure a five handily.) 

The best two holes are nine and eighteen. Nine is a dogleg left that entices players to cut the corner, however, the smart play is out to the fairway bunker which opens up the angle into a green guarded by water left. Eighteen is a straightaway par four with water on the left and red stakes on the right. A good drive leaves a mid iron approach over water and sand. Even this early in his architectural career, Nicklaus had a penchant for finishing off his outgoing and incoming nines strongly. 

(The second par three on the ocean feels cluttered with the plants and palmetto bushes breaking up the view. The wind has a huge impact yet the lack of references makes it hard to judge. The villas are just beyond the bushes to the right. The picture used in advertisements is from their balcony.) 

Golfers debate which course is better, Osprey or Turtle? Many publications put Jack’s course ahead so I’ll let architect Brian Curly make the call. He recollected that if the Ocean Course wasn’t ready in time for the Ryder Cup, the contingency plan was Osprey. Enough said. I give Turtle Point a 5 (good)(worth driving an hour to play).

[It hurts looking at this scorecard. I got off to a decent start, and totally lost it at the turn. Everyone in the group made a birdie. That’s always a great thing. My birdie came on one of the ocean holes. I thinned a 5hy about four feet off the ground, watched as it ran at least fifty yards before exhausting its last breathe two feet from the hole. Better to be lucky than good. It cost $225. A hundred more than I think it deserves.]

Great group of guys making memories at Kiawah!